Oliver, in short
Record the decision in your risk assessment or policies: which of HMRC's triggers you checked (more than one premises, branches or agents, high client turnover, cross-border work, complex delivery), why none applies, how you monitor compliance instead, who approved it and when. Revisit it at every annual review or business change.
Why a record matters. Regulation 21(1)(c) requires an independent audit function only "where appropriate with regard to the size and nature" of your business. Deciding it is not appropriate is allowed, but at an inspection you need to show you made that decision deliberately and on the right factors.
What to write (a short paragraph in your risk assessment or policies is enough)
- The triggers you checked. HMRC (AMLG1900 section 9.2) expects the extra controls if you have: more than one premises; branches or agents; high customer turnover; non-domestic or cross-border work; complex ways of delivering services. State each and whether it applies.
- The wider factors. HMRC also asks you to consider the nature, scale and complexity of the business, the diversity of operations, the volume and size of transactions, and the risk in each area. One line each.
- Your conclusion and reasons. For example: "Single office, four staff, all local residential sales, about 60 instructions a year, no agents. An independent audit function is not proportionate."
- What you do instead. Every firm must still monitor compliance with its procedures (regulation 19(3)(e)). Describe your file sampling: who reviews, how many files, how often, and where results go.
- Approval and date. Name the senior manager who approved it.
- Review triggers. Opening a branch, taking on agents, a jump in volume or overseas clients means you revisit the decision.
Keep the evidence. File review results, actions taken and the annual review note show the decision works. HMRC wants weaknesses documented together with "the action taken to address the weakness".
Sector difference: accountants. CCAB guidance says accountancy businesses "must introduce a system of regular, independent reviews", proportionate to size, and that independent "does not necessarily mean external". Only a sole practitioner with no relevant employees is excused. So a small accountancy practice with staff should plan a proportionate independent review (for example by a partner not involved in the files reviewed, or an external reviewer) rather than recording that none is needed.
This is general information, not legal advice; your supervisor's guidance takes priority.
Sources
Still have a question?
Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.
Ask Oliver Email the team