Oliver, in short
Only where appropriate to your size and nature. Regulation 21(1)(c) then requires an independent audit function that examines whether your AML policies and procedures are adequate and effective, makes recommendations and checks they are followed. HMRC expects it where a firm has several premises, branches or agents, high customer turnover, cross-border work or complex delivery.
What the law requires. Regulation 21(1)(c) requires firms, where appropriate with regard to their size and nature, to set up an independent audit function. That function must:
- examine and evaluate whether your policies, controls and procedures (PCPs) are adequate and effective;
- make recommendations;
- check that the recommendations are carried out.
Who needs it. HMRC groups the independent audit with the compliance officer and employee screening as "additional" controls. It expects them where a business has more than one premises, uses branches or agents, has a high turnover of customers, works across borders or delivers services in complex ways (AMLG1900 section 9.2). A sole practitioner who neither employs nor works in association with anyone else is outside regulation 21(1) altogether. Record your decision and reasons in your risk assessment.
Independent of what? The regulations do not say the audit must be external. The point is that the reviewer is independent of the work being reviewed. In a larger firm that may be an internal audit team or a colleague outside the AML process. In a smaller firm that needs one, an external reviewer is often the practical way to get independence. Supervisors' guidance may say more about this.
Even if you don't need a formal audit, every firm must monitor compliance with its PCPs (regulation 19(3)(e)). HMRC recommends quality assurance that tests a sample of client files and transactions against your procedures. HMRC inspection guidance says officers may ask to see internal audits and any external auditor's report covering AML compliance.
What a useful audit looks at
- Is the firm-wide risk assessment current, specific and reviewed?
- Do the PCPs match what staff actually do?
- File sampling: identity verified before work started, beneficial owners identified, risk rating recorded, enhanced due diligence where required.
- Suspicion reporting: internal reports logged and decisions recorded.
- Training records complete; HMRC registration details up to date.
Act on the findings and record what you changed. HMRC stresses that an audit does not move responsibility away from the business.
Sources
Still have a question?
Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.
Ask Oliver Email the team