Oliver / Questions

How should the MLRO record a decision not to file a SAR?

UKChecked answer · verified 29 October 2026 · next review 29 April 2027

Oliver, in short

In writing, for every internal report: what was reported and when, what the MLRO checked, the reasons the facts did not amount to knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds, who decided and when. HMRC expects this record. It is the MLRO's evidence if the decision is later questioned, because failing to report can be an offence judged objectively.

Why record it

Regulation 21(5) of the Money Laundering Regulations requires the nominated officer (MLRO) to consider every internal report against the information the firm holds and decide whether it gives rise to knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds to suspect. If the MLRO decides not to report, POCA section 331 still applies an objective test: the question later may be whether there were reasonable grounds, whatever the MLRO actually thought. A clear contemporaneous record is the best evidence that the decision was reasoned. HMRC says it expects to see the record, the risk assessment and the reasons, whichever way the decision goes.

What to include (one entry per internal report)

  1. Reference number, date and time the internal report was received, and who made it.
  2. The client or matter, and a short summary of what was reported.
  3. What the MLRO reviewed: CDD file, source of funds evidence, transaction history, open-source searches, questions put to the client (and the answers).
  4. The analysis: which facts were concerning, what explains them, and why the MLRO concluded there is no knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds.
  5. The decision ("no SAR"), the date, and who made it (and anyone consulted, such as the deputy or a lawyer).
  6. Follow-up actions: raise the risk rating, extra monitoring, a review date, or a note to report if X happens.
  7. Feedback to the person who reported, so they know their legal duty is met.

Good practice

  • Write it at the time, not after an inspection is announced.
  • Use facts, not "no concerns". An inspector should be able to follow the reasoning.
  • Keep the log apart from the client file, with access limited, as with SAR copies.
  • Revisit the decision if new information arrives. A "no SAR" decision is not permanent.
  • Count decisions (reports received, SARs made, no-SAR decisions) in your annual MLRO report, without identifying details if the report is widely circulated.

How long to keep it

The MLRs set five-year retention for due diligence and transaction records (regulation 40), but do not name internal reports. Many firms keep the MLRO log for at least as long as the related client records. Check your supervisor's guidance and record the retention period in your policy.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. HMRC AMLG11100, section 11.2 (important note on decisions not to submit) (source updated 17 July 2026)
  2. HMRC AMLG11100, section 11.1 Suspicious indicators (source updated 17 July 2026)
  3. MLR 2017, regulation 21(5) (nominated officer must consider internal disclosures)
  4. Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, section 331(2) (nominated officer's failure to disclose)

Researched from primary sources and checked by a separate fact-checker. General information, not legal advice.

Still have a question?

Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.

Ask Oliver Email the team