Oliver / Questions

How do I challenge an HMRC money laundering penalty?

UKChecked answer · verified 29 October 2026 · next review 29 April 2027

Oliver, in short

HMRC must offer a review, usually by an officer not involved in the decision. Accept within 30 days; HMRC must reply within 45 days unless you agree otherwise. You can then appeal to the tax tribunal within 30 days of the conclusion, or appeal directly within 30 days of the decision. The tribunal can cancel or reduce the penalty.

Part 10 of the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (regulations 94 to 100) sets out how to challenge HMRC decisions as an AML supervisor.

Which decisions you can challenge (regulation 99)

  • A penalty or a published censure (regulation 76).
  • A prohibition on management (regulation 78).
  • A refusal to register, or a suspension or cancellation of registration.
  • A finding that someone is not fit and proper.
  • A direction under regulation 25.

Step 1: HMRC review (optional)

HMRC must offer a review when it tells you about a decision you can appeal (regulation 94). GOV.UK says the review is usually by an officer who was not involved. Accept within 30 days of the offer. HMRC must give its conclusion within 45 days unless you agree a different period; if it misses that deadline, the decision is treated as upheld (regulation 98). The review can uphold, vary or cancel the decision. If you miss the 30 days, HMRC must still review if you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay (regulation 97).

Step 2: appeal to the tribunal

  • Without a review: within 30 days of the decision notice.
  • After a review: within 30 days of the review conclusion.
  • Late appeals need the tribunal's permission.

Appeals go to the tribunal as defined for VAT appeals (in practice the First-tier Tribunal, Tax Chamber). It can quash or vary the decision, reduce a penalty to nil, or substitute its own decision.

Important practical points

  • If the decision was to refuse, suspend or cancel registration, you cannot carry out regulated activity while the review is under way.
  • HMRC asks for disagreements about suspension or cancellation to be sent to Fraud Investigation Service, FIS Individuals & Business, SO987, Newcastle, NE98 1ZZ.
  • HMRC publishes penalties and must also publish the status and outcome of any appeal (regulation 85(2)).
  • Under regulation 76(4), you have a defence if you took all reasonable steps and exercised all due diligence. Gather evidence of your policies, training and checks.

FCA decisions are appealed to the Upper Tribunal instead (regulation 93). Professional body decisions follow each body's own disciplinary and appeal rules.

This is general information, not legal advice. Consider professional advice before appealing.

Sources

  1. MLR 2017, regulation 95(1) (review by the Commissioners)
  2. MLR 2017, regulation 100(1)–(2) (time limits for appeals)
  3. MLR 2017, regulation 99(4) (tribunal powers)
  4. GOV.UK (HMRC), Money laundering supervision sanctions and appeals (updated 28 Jan 2026)

Researched from primary sources and checked by a separate fact-checker. General information, not legal advice.

Still have a question?

Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.

Ask Oliver Email the team
Ask Oliver a follow-upHe has read this page too