Oliver / Questions

What reasonable prevention procedures defend against the failure to prevent tax evasion offence?

UKChecked answer · verified 30 October 2026 · next review 30 April 2027

Oliver, in short

The defence is proving you had prevention procedures that were reasonable in all the circumstances, or that none were reasonable to expect. Government guidance builds them on six principles: risk assessment, proportionate procedures, top-level commitment, due diligence, communication and training, and monitoring and review. Small, lower-risk firms can do this simply but must document it.

Under section 45 (UK tax) and section 46 (foreign tax) of the Criminal Finances Act 2017, a company or partnership is guilty if someone acting for it criminally facilitates tax evasion. Its only defence is to prove it had reasonable prevention procedures, or that it was not reasonable to expect any. The government guidance (September 2017, still the current version on GOV.UK) sets out six principles.

The six principles

  1. Risk assessment. Assess where staff, agents and contractors could help clients or suppliers evade tax. "Sit at the desk" of each role and ask about motive, means and opportunity. Document it and keep it under review.
  2. Proportionality. Procedures should match the risk and your size and complexity. The guidance says the offences need "more than mere lip-service" but not "excessively burdensome procedures".
  3. Top-level commitment. Partners or directors should own the policy and set a culture where helping evasion is never acceptable.
  4. Due diligence. Apply risk-based checks to people who perform services for you, such as subcontractors and introducers.
  5. Communication and training. Make sure policies are understood, with training proportionate to the risk.
  6. Monitoring and review. Check the procedures work and update them as risks change.

What a small, lower-risk firm might do (section 4 of the guidance)

  • A short written risk assessment, including red flags such as staff who never take leave or guard client files.
  • A clear statement from the partners or directors against all tax evasion.
  • Contract terms requiring staff and contractors not to facilitate evasion and to report concerns.
  • Regular training, which can sit inside AML and fraud training.
  • A whistleblowing route, pay and bonus structures that do not reward turning a blind eye, and periodic reviews.

How this fits with AML

Most regulated firms can extend existing AML controls: add tax evasion facilitation to the firm-wide risk assessment, policy, training and second-pair-of-eyes file reviews. Keep evidence of when each step was done; the burden of proof is on the firm.

Common mistakes

  • Adding the word "tax" to an AML policy without assessing the actual risk.
  • Ignoring associated persons who are not employees, such as agents.
  • No record of training or reviews.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. Criminal Finances Act 2017, section 45(2) (defence)
  2. GOV.UK, Corporate offences for failing to prevent criminal facilitation of tax evasion (guidance page), Summary (source updated 18 May 2018)
  3. HM Government, Tackling tax evasion - Government guidance for the corporate offences of failure to prevent the criminal facilitation of tax evasion (1 Sep 2017), Principle 2, p 21, Principle 2, page 21 (source updated 1 September 2017)
  4. HM Government, Tackling tax evasion guidance, Principle 1, p 16, Principle 1, page 16 (source updated 1 September 2017)
  5. HM Government, Tackling tax evasion guidance, section 4, Suggested reasonable prevention procedures for lower risk SMEs, p 47, Section 4, page 47 (source updated 1 September 2017)
  6. HM Government, Tackling tax evasion guidance, case study (light-touch assessment), p 10, Case study, page 10 (source updated 1 September 2017)

Researched from primary sources and checked by a separate fact-checker. General information, not legal advice.

Still have a question?

Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.

Ask Oliver Email the team
Ask Oliver a follow-upHe has read this page too