Oliver, in short
No. A firm need not disclose personal data where that would be likely to prejudice the prevention or detection of crime (Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 2), and must not reveal a suspicious activity report where that would be tipping off. Answer the rest of the request as normal, decide case by case and record why.
Note the clash of initials: under UK GDPR a "SAR" is a subject access request; in AML it is a suspicious activity report. Below, "subject access request" is written in full.
The two rules that limit disclosure
- Crime exemption. Schedule 2, paragraph 2 of the Data Protection Act 2018 switches off the right of access for data processed to prevent, investigate or detect crime, but only "to the extent" that complying "would be likely to prejudice" those purposes.
- Tipping off. Section 333A of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 makes it an offence in the regulated sector to disclose that a suspicious activity report has been made (to the nominated officer or the NCA) where that is likely to prejudice an investigation. Maximum sentence on indictment: two years, a fine or both.
So the subject access request does not override tipping off. Data whose disclosure would tip someone off is normally covered by the crime exemption. CCAB guidance says both exceptions apply to records of internal suspicion reports and suspicious activity reports.
What it does not let you do
- Refuse the whole request. The ICO says you "cannot use the exemption to justify denying access to whole categories of personal information" if disclosure would not cause prejudice. Provide identity documents, correspondence and account records as usual.
- Apply it automatically. Decide each time; CCAB notes that data exempt once "may no longer be exempt" later, for example once a suspicion has been proved false.
A practical process
- Route every subject access request from a current or recent client past the nominated officer (MLRO) before replying.
- Keep suspicion records separate from client files, so routine replies do not sweep them in.
- Withhold only the prejudicial parts. Your reply may be more general where saying that an exemption applies would itself prejudice it (ICO).
- Record the reasons for withholding.
- Reply within the normal time limit: one month, extendable in some cases.
For a difficult case, take legal advice. This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 2(1) (crime and taxation exemption), Sch 2 para 2(1)
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, section 333A(1)-(2) (tipping off: regulated sector)
- ICO, "What exemptions are relevant for SARs?" (right of access guidance, updated 8 December 2025), Crime and taxation: general; What are exemptions and how do they work?
- CCAB AMLGAS (law as at 1 July 2026), paragraphs 6.7.4-6.7.5
Still have a question?
Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.
Ask Oliver Email the team