Oliver, in short
Usually not. CCAB guidance says an innocent error or mistake would not normally create criminal proceeds, so there is nothing to report. Explain the error to the client; they must then promptly put it right. If they refuse or you come to suspect dishonesty, the benefit can become criminal property and a report may be needed.
The starting point. A suspicious activity report (SAR) is about money laundering, which needs criminal property: a benefit from criminal conduct. The CCAB guidance for accountants (AMLGAS, July 2026) says an innocent error or mistake "would not normally give rise to criminal proceeds (unless a strict liability offence)" (6.1.13). Where it is a genuine mistake, there is normally nothing to report.
What to do when you find an error
- Explain it to the client. AMLGAS says the client should have the situation explained to them.
- The client must put it right promptly, for example by amending a return or telling HMRC, "to avoid committing a money laundering offence".
- Get specialist help where the legal position is outside your expertise.
- Record what you found, what you told the client and what they did.
When it can become reportable
- The client refuses or delays correcting a known underpayment. AMLGAS says the client must put things right promptly "to avoid committing a money laundering offence", so a refusal can change the picture.
- The facts point to dishonesty, for example a pattern, concealed records or a "mistake" that always favours the client.
- You have reasonable grounds to suspect, judged objectively by what a reasonable professional in your position would think (AMLGAS 6.1.7). You don't need proof, but a vague unease is not suspicion.
At that point, make an internal report to your nominated officer (MLRO), or to the National Crime Agency if you are a sole practitioner with no staff. Don't tip the client off.
Strict liability. AMLGAS flags strict liability offences as the exception: where an offence needs no dishonesty, the benefit may still be criminal property. If unsure, ask your MLRO or your supervisor's helpline.
General information, not legal advice.
Sources
Still have a question?
Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.
Ask Oliver Email the team