Oliver / Questions

Is a genuine tax mistake by a client reportable?

UKChecked answer · verified 29 October 2026 · next review 29 April 2027

Oliver, in short

Usually not. CCAB guidance says an innocent error or mistake would not normally create criminal proceeds, so there is nothing to report. Explain the error to the client; they must then promptly put it right. If they refuse or you come to suspect dishonesty, the benefit can become criminal property and a report may be needed.

The starting point. A suspicious activity report (SAR) is about money laundering, which needs criminal property: a benefit from criminal conduct. The CCAB guidance for accountants (AMLGAS, July 2026) says an innocent error or mistake "would not normally give rise to criminal proceeds (unless a strict liability offence)" (6.1.13). Where it is a genuine mistake, there is normally nothing to report.

What to do when you find an error

  1. Explain it to the client. AMLGAS says the client should have the situation explained to them.
  2. The client must put it right promptly, for example by amending a return or telling HMRC, "to avoid committing a money laundering offence".
  3. Get specialist help where the legal position is outside your expertise.
  4. Record what you found, what you told the client and what they did.

When it can become reportable

  • The client refuses or delays correcting a known underpayment. AMLGAS says the client must put things right promptly "to avoid committing a money laundering offence", so a refusal can change the picture.
  • The facts point to dishonesty, for example a pattern, concealed records or a "mistake" that always favours the client.
  • You have reasonable grounds to suspect, judged objectively by what a reasonable professional in your position would think (AMLGAS 6.1.7). You don't need proof, but a vague unease is not suspicion.

At that point, make an internal report to your nominated officer (MLRO), or to the National Crime Agency if you are a sole practitioner with no staff. Don't tip the client off.

Strict liability. AMLGAS flags strict liability offences as the exception: where an offence needs no dishonesty, the benefit may still be criminal property. If unsure, ask your MLRO or your supervisor's helpline.

General information, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. CCAB AMLGAS (July 2026), paragraph 6.1.13 (source updated 5 August 2026)
  2. CCAB AMLGAS (July 2026), paragraphs 6.1.5–6.1.7 (suspicion and reasonable grounds) (source updated 5 August 2026)
  3. Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, section 330(2)
  4. CCAB AMLGAS (July 2026), paragraph 3.3.1 (sole practitioners) (source updated 5 August 2026)

Researched from primary sources and checked by a separate fact-checker. General information, not legal advice.

Still have a question?

Ask Oliver in your own words, or send it to the AML Buddy team and we’ll use it to add a checked answer.

Ask Oliver Email the team